Soft Response and Soil-Pile Interaction During Seismic Shaking
 
 

is well-known that local site conditions can significantly affect the nature and intensity of earthquake tremors. For example, the severe damage caused by the 1985 Michoacan earthquake is largely attributed to the significant site effect caused by the presence of a thick soft soil deposit

which leads to substantial amplification in ground motion. Soft soil conditions are also known to have resulted in amplification of earthquake shaking. Many big cities, including Singapore, Bangkok, Kuala Lumpur, Shanghai and Jakarta, are underlain by thick deposits of soft clays, and piles are widely used as foundation elements for infrastructure. Anecdotal evidence indicates that seismic tremors are much more often felt in buildings built on top of soft soil strata than other types of soils. This problem is being studied by a research group in the Department of Civil Engineering.

A large part of this study comprises dynamic centrifuge model tests (Figures 1 and 2) conducted at the NUS Geotechnical Centrifuge Laboratory on pure soft clay beds, both with and without pile supported structures. The input motions for the centrifuge experiments were generated using response spectra from earthquakes measured in Singapore from Sumatran events. However, the magnitudes of the acceleration were artificially tuned to give the desired intensity

Model tests on soft marine clay layers without foundation elements showed significant amplification of earthquake motion by soft marine clay layers. The amplification ranged from 2 to 6 depending on the peak ground acceleration of the input motion. For large input acceleration having peaks of about 0.1g or higher, the amplification was about 2. However, for smaller input acceleration with peaks of about 0.02g or less, the amplification increased to about 6. In all cases, the maximum amplification occured within the frequency band ranging from 0.4 Hz to 0.8 Hz. This means that amplification is higher for smaller tremors. For regions where the norm is to design for relatively small earth tremors, the effect of site amplification is therefore correspondingly more significant. The above results were obtained from tests on Singapore marine clay which is a high-plasticity clay. Tests on kaolin show a different trend, with amplification increasing slightly with input acceleration. This can be explained by the difference in damping characteristics between the two soils. Hence, while the general trend of amplification remains unchanged, detailed features of the site response are highly dependent upon soil type and earthquake motion.

The model results were compared against field data recorded by seismological stations in Singapore. The field data was recorded at rock and stiff soil sites as well as soft soil sites. Analysis of the field data showed that, for the recorded earthquakes, all of which have peak ground acceleration well below 0.02g, the typical amplification by soft soil sites is between 5 and 6. This agrees well with the model test results.

The current phase of the study is focused upon the interaction between soft soil strata and pile foundations during seismic shaking. This is an important issue since many tall buildings in Singapore are supported on pile foundations. The results obtained to-date show that there are significant soil-pile effects which cause the resonance periods of the ground motion and pile-raft structure to differ from their respective uncoupled resonance periods. Secondly, for the case of short piles in soft clays, ground surface motions may not be representative of pile-raft motion. Furthermore, a pile in soft clay under earthquake excitation behaves quite differently from the same pile loaded dynamically from the pile top. In the latter case, the soil around the pile has a restraining effect on it. In the former, the centrifuge model results show that the soil actually applies an inertial loading onto the pile. In view of this, it seems highly questionable whether dynamic or cyclic pile load tests will shed any light on the response of such piles to earthquake loading. Longer and more flexible piles are currently being investigated.

 

 
 


Contact person

Assoc Prof FH Lee
Tel: 6516 2274, Fax: 6779 1635
E-mail: cveleefh@nus.edu.sg

 

 
 

4